Transcript
Good morning. Good morning, San Diego. Welcome back to Coastlines to Cranes, the podcast where we are exploring the people, places, and big ideas that shape the future of building in America, especially America's finest city, from coast to the job site and everywhere in between. I'm Shandon Harbour, your host, and welcome back. Thank you for being with us again on this Wednesday morning, sipping your coffee on your way to work, potentially already at coffee having lunch. Today, we are bringing you about political advocacy and talking about ABC and why it is so important to keep construction open, free and open competition in America, land of the free, home of the brave.
Let's start with why are you even talking about open in construction? That seems sort of obvious that in America, you should be able to work wherever you want to. You should have the choice of where you'd like to go to school, the choices of where you'd like to work, and the choice of whether or not you would like to be a union member or not. However, in San Diego, in California, are things called project labor agreements, and a project labor agreement is also called a community workforce agreement, a PLA, and there's a host of other names that a project labor agreement has been named in different political discussions.
Let's go way back to how did this even come about? So, I was recently in Boston, and I always have to laugh because whenever I go under the tunnel there, it is an engineering feat. For any of you that are familiar with Boston, there is something called the Boston Tunnel, runs under the bay, the Boston Bay, and it was called the Big Dig. In order to build a tunnel, they had to have an engineering miracle, truly, on being able to dig under the bay there. It's a fascinating story. It was one of the first project labor agreements, and the reason for it was because in union membership, every trade has its own business manager that negotiates terms for that union and that trade.
And so, each specific trade had negotiated collective bargaining agreements. When you come together on a project, oftentimes, there could be conflicting terms for each different union trade. So, for example, if Labor Day was a day off for the electricians, it might not be a day off for the sheet metal workers. So, how do you establish the common ground with all trades? It was called a project labor agreement, and every trade signs on to the agreement that agrees to the terms in the project labor agreement. Now, on face value, one would think, well, that seems harmless.
That's fine. That makes complete sense. And for those that are presented with a project labor agreement, the owners or the developers, yes, we want peace. We don't want strikes. We don't want any of those things happening on our job site. So, we're going to do a project labor agreement. What it doesn't account for is for those that are not signatory to a union. If you're not a signatory construction company, then you have no way to participate in a project labor agreement. And so, over the years, project labor agreements have become weaponized, and they have been used by politicians to exclude the open shop or the non-union contractors.
Now, many will say, no, Shandon, that's not true. They can bid on the work. Yes, that is correct. They can bid on the work. However, the fine print will sometimes say you have to have all your employees join the union for the duration of the project, and the employees must contribute to the pensions and to the medical programs of the union programs. However, that doesn't make sense if my company has its own 401k and its own medical program. So, many times, contractors will opt not to participate with a project labor agreement. The other fine print is that it will say you must use union workers and or union apprentices, which people will say, well, why does it say that?
Well, they're going to want the union workers to work on the project. And the reason for that is because our apprenticeship programs are evaluated on graduation rates. In order to graduate, you have to have a certain amount of hours. So, if our electrical program says you have to have 8,000 hours to graduate, then the way you get those 8,000 hours is by being on the job. However, if you're not able to work on a project, you sit on the bench. So, if you can go back to that analogy I gave in a previous episode about two football teams on the football field or two programs, USC and UCLA, it would be the same as saying, all right, if ABC is USC, you guys all sit on the bench and then UCLA gets to run all their players.
It's not a very fair game, is it? So, many times, those that are not in the union or not non-signatory to unions, they will not participate in a project labor agreement. The last thing I'll say is that if you've ever had a team or a workforce and they say, yes, you can participate in this event or this project, but you can't use any of your workers. You have to use these folks. Well, that makes it infinitely more difficult because we don't know those people. We don't know how they like to work. We don't know the ins and outs of that.
And our workforce has a relationship with us. So, I like to say to those that are in the political world, it would be the equivalent of me saying, yes, you can participate, but we're going to use this other legislator's chief of staff. You can't use your own chief of staff. That would be very difficult to do. And so, essentially, that's what project labor agreements say is that you cannot use your team. You have to use the other team. And so, it's become a weaponized vehicle for those to exclude the open shop or the non-union or the merit shop folks because we'll be sitting on the bench and the rest of the teams are out there on the playing field.
And so when it comes to political advocacy and the importance of our discussions and educating the legislators, what lawmakers don't usually understand is how this all ties to graduation and how you have to be on the job to graduate and maintain our program graduation numbers. So if all the work is only going to one team, the other team is not getting the hours or the ability to graduate. And if you are a lawmaker and you're listening out there, the key thing is all of our folks are constituents in your districts. They are San Diego and California taxpayers.
They are buying cars and they are buying homes in your district. They are putting their children through your school systems and they are gainful, great citizens in your communities. And to not permit them to have the choice of how they want to be on a construction project is really detrimental to the overall community. So when it gets down to freedom to work and freedom to build, the critical piece is making sure that we are all understanding the importance of open competition. Let the best man or woman win. Let the best company bid. The last thing that I'll say about a project labor agreement is that by naturally not having other companies participate and bid on the work, it inevitably creates a false increase in costs because you have less competition bidding for the work.
So there's any time you have a single monopoly, as you would say, or one or two companies bidding, or I mean, usually the last few ones, I haven't seen very many people bid at all, but it drives up the cost because the margins, there's no competition there to really keep the prices lower or to drive a more competitive environment for the work. So in the end, the taxpayers just paying for a lot more. So there you have it. PLA 101 wrapped up in one Coastlines to Cranes's podcast. And if any of you have more to say about this, we'd love your feedback.
Read the show notes. Stay classy, San Diego. See you next time.
We'll see you next time.